Praxis in Left-Handers

Gregory Króliczak

Abstrakt


Neuropsychological and neuroimaging evidence convincingly implicates the left cerebral hemisphere in the representation of skilled movements (praxis) in right-handers. Compelling and consistent data on the organization of praxis in left - handed individuals has only recently started to emerge. This new evidence, again both from neuropsychology and neuroimaging, supports the notion that in left-handers the neural substrate of praxis skills is less asymmetric, i.e., it is more bilaterally organized. Up until recently, though, the neuropsychological literature on brain-damaged left-handers was often dominated by descriptions of more or less atypical cases and dissociations of functions observed in such individuals. Associations of deficits, linked to anatomic proximity rather than to a common cerebral specialization, were rarely found worth publishing and/or in-depth discussions. This paper first reviews some of the most relevant and/or well-known reports on representations of different categories of skilled manual gestures in right- and left-handers, with a view to support the idea that these skills are mediated by a common system. Then, based on neuroimaging evidence from healthy subjects, a few individuals with unusual organization of praxis are discussed. These disparate cases quite likely represent natural variation in functional asymmetries. It is yet to be determined whether the effect of a more bilateral organization of cognitive skills in this population is just due to a much higher incidence of atypical representations of functions or rather a general tendency for all left-handers to have their brains less asymmetrically organized.


Słowa kluczowe


communicative gestures; gesture planning; neural representations; asymmetries; dissociations

Pełny tekst:

PDF

Bibliografia


Binkofski F., Buxbaum L.J., Two Action Systems in the Human Brain, “Brain and Language” 2012.

Bohlhalter S., Hattori N., Wheaton L., Fridman E., Shamim E.A., Garraux G., Hallett M., Gesture Subtype-Dependent Left Lateralization of Praxis Planning: An Event-Related fMRI Study, “Cereb Cortex” 2009, No. 19(6).

Brinkman J., Kuypers H.G., Splitbrain Monkeys: Cerebral Control of Ipsilateral and Contralateral Arm, Hand, and Finger Movements, “Science” 1972, No. 176(34).

Brinkman J., Kuypers H.G., Cerebral Control of Contralateral and Ipsilateral Arm, Hand and Finger Movements in the Split-Brain Rhesus Monkey, “Brain” 1973, No. 96(4).

Buxbaum L., Ideomotor Apraxia: A Call to Action, “Neurocase” 2001, No. 7(6).

Carmo J., RRumiati I., Imitation of Transitive and Intransitive Actions in Healthy Individuals, “Brain Cogn” 2009, No. 69(3).

Caspers S., Geyer S., Schleicher A., Mohlberg H., Amunts K., Zilles K., The Human Inferior Parietal Cortex: Cytoarchitectonic Parcellation and Interindividual Variability, “Neuroimage” 2006, No. 33(2).

Chlebus P., Mikl M., Brazdil M., Pazourkova M., Krupa P., Rektor I., fMRI Evaluation of Hemispheric Language Dominance Using Various Methods of Laterality Index Calculation, “Exp Brain Res” 2007, No. 179(3).

Choi S., Na D.L., Kang E., Lee K.M., Lee S.W., Na D.G., Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging During Pantomiming Tool-use Gestures, “Exp Brain Res” 2001, No. 139(3).

Cubelli R., Marchetti C., Boscolo G., Della Sala S., Cognition in Action: Testing a Model of Limb Apraxia, “Brain Cogn” 2000, No. 44(2).

De Renzi E., Lucchelli F., Ideational Apraxia, “Brain” 1988, No. 111.

Dejerine J., Contribution a l’etude de l’aphasie chez les gauchers, “Revue neurol.” 1912, No. 24.

Delis D., Knight R.T., Simpson G., Reversed Hemispheric Organization in a Left-Hander, “Neuropsychologia” 1983, No. 21(1).

Dumont C., Ska B., Schiavetto A., Selective Impairment of Transitive Gestures: An Unusual Case of Apraxia, “Neurocase” 1999, No. 5.

Eickhoff S.B., Paus T., Caspers S., Grosbras M.H., Evans A.C., Zilles K., Amunts K., Assignment of Functional Activations to Probabilistic Cytoarchitectonic Areas Revisited, “Neuroimage” 2007, No. 36(3).

Falchook A., Burtis D.B., Acosta L.M., Salazar L., Hedna V.S., Khanna A.Y., Heilman K.M., Praxis and Writing in a Right-Hander with Crossed Aphasia, “Neurocase” 2013.

Fischer R., Alexander M.P., Gabriel C., Gould E., Milione J., Reversed Lateralization of Cognitive Functions in Right Handers. Exceptions to Classical Aphasiology, “Brain” 1991, No. 114.

Foundas A., Macauley B.L., Raymer A.M., Maher L.M., Rothi L.J., Heilman K.M., Ideomotor Apraxia in Alzheimer Disease and Left Hemisphere Stroke: Limb Transitive and Intransitive Movements, “Neuropsychiatry Neuropsychol Behav Neurol” 1999, No. 12(3).

Freund H., The Apraxias [in:] Diseases of the Nervous System. Clinical Neurobiology, A.K. Asbury, G.M. McKhann, aW.J. McDonald (eds.), Philadelphia 1992.

Freund H., Hummelsheim H., Lesions of Premotor Cortex in Man, “Brain” 1985, No. 108.

Frey S., What Puts the how in where? Tool Use and the Divided Visual Streams Hypothesis, “Cortex” 2007, No. 43(3).

Frey S., Funnell M.G., Gerry V.E., Gazzaniga M.S., A Dissociation Between the Representation of Tool-Use Skills and Hand Dominance: Insights from Left - and Right-Handed Callosotomy Patients, “J Cogn Neurosci” 2005, No. 17(2).

Fridman E., Immisch I., Hanakawa T., Bohlhalter S., Waldvogel D., Kansaku K., Wheaton L., Wu T., Hallett M., The Role of the Dorsal Stream for Gesture Production, “Neuroimage” 2006, No. 29(2).

Gazzaniga M., Bogen J.E., Sperry R.W., Dyspraxia following Division of the Cerebral Commissures, “Arch Neurol” 1967, No. 16(6).

Geschwind N., Kaplan E., A Human Cerebral Deconnection Syndrome. A Preliminary Report, “Neurology” 1962, No. 12.

Goldenberg G., Apraxia in Left-handers, “Brain” 2013, No. 136(8).

Goldenberg G., Hermsdorfer J., Glindemann R., Rorden C., Karnath H.O., Pantomime of Tool Use Depends on Integrity of Left Inferior Frontal Cortex, “Cereb Cortex” 2007, No. 17(12).

Goodglass H., Kaplan E., Disturbance of Gesture and Pantomime in Aphasia, “Brain” 1963, No. 86.

Haaland K., Harrington D.L., Hemispheric Asymmetry of Movement, “Curr Opin Neurobiol” 1996, No. 6(6).

Haaland K., Harrington D.L., Knight R.T., Neural Representations of Skilled Movement, “Brain” 2000, No. 123.

Hanna-Pladdy B., Daniels S.K., Fieselman M.A., Thompson K., Vasterling J.J., Heilman K.M., Foundas A.L., Praxis Lateralization: Errors in Right and Left Hemisphere Stroke, “Cortex” 2001, No. 37(2).

Heath M., Roy E.A., Black S.E., Westwood D.A., Intransitive Limb Gestures and Apraxia Following Unilateral Stroke, “J Clin Exp Neuropsychol” 2001, No. 23(5).

Heath M., Roy E.A., Westwood D., Black S.E., Patterns of Apraxia Associated with the Production of Intransitive Limb Gestures Following Left and Right Hemisphere Stroke, “Brain Cogn” 2001, No. 46(1 – 2).

Heilman K., Coyle J.M., Gonyea E.F., Geschwind N., Apraxia and Agraphia in a Left-Hander, “Brain” 1973, No. 96(1).

Heilman K., Maher L.M., Greenwald M.L., Rothi L.J., Conceptual Apraxia from Lateralized Lesions, “Neurology” 1997, No. 49(2).

Heilman K., Meador K.J., Loring D.W., Hemispheric Asymmetries of Limb-kinetic Apraxia: A Loss of Deftness, “Neurology” 2000, No. 55(4).

Heilman K., Rothi L.J., Valenstein E., Two Forms of Ideomotor Apraxia, “Neurology” 1982, No. 32(4).

Heilman K., Rothi L.J., Apraxia [in:] Clinical Neuropsychology, K.M. Heilman, E. Valenstein (eds.), New York 2003.

Heilman K., Watson R.T., Rothi L.G., Limb Apraxias: Disorders of Skilled Movements [in:] Behavioural Neurology and Neuropsychology, T.E. Feinberg, M.J. Farah (eds.), New York 1997.

Johnson-Frey S., The Neural Bases of Complex Tool Use in Humans, “Trends Cogn Sci” 2004, No. 8(2).

Johnson-Frey S., Newman-Norlund R., Graft on S.T., A Distributed Left Hemisphere Network Active During Planning of Everyday Tool Use Skills, “Cereb Cortex” 2005, No. 15(6).

Kimura D., Speech Representation in an Unbiased Sample of Left-Handers, “Hum Neurobiol” 1983, No. 2(3).

Kimura D., Archibald Y., Motor Functions of the Left Hemisphere, “Brain” 1974, No. 97(2).

Knecht S., Drager B., Deppe M., Bobe L., Lohmann H., Floel A., Ringelstein E.B., Henningsen H., Handedness and Hemispheric Language Dominance in Healthy Humans, “Brain” 2000, No. 123.

Knecht S., Jansen A., Frank A., Randenborgh van J., Sommer J., Kanowski M., Heinze H.J., How Atypical is Atypical Language Dominance?, “Neuroimage” 2003, No. 18(4).

Króliczak G., Reprezentacja praksji u osób prawo- i leworęcznych [Representation of Praxis in Right- and Left-Handed Individuals] [in:] Na ścieżkach neuronauki [On Paths of Neuroscience], P. Francuz (ed.), Lublin 2010.

Króliczak G., Representations of Transitive and Intransitive Gestures: Perception and Imitation, “Journal of Neuroscience and Neuroengineering” 2013, No. 2(3).

Króliczak G., Cavina Pratesi C., Large M.E., Object Perception Versus Target-directed Manual Actions [in:] Neuroadaptive Systems: Theory and Applications, M. Fafrowicz, T. Marek, W. Karwowski, D. Schmorrow (eds.), Bosa Roca 2012.

Króliczak G., Cavina-Pratesi C., Goodman D.A., Culham J.C., What Does the Brain Do when You Fake It? An FMRI Study of Pantomimed and Real Grasping, “Journal of Neurophysiology” 2007, No. 97(3).

Króliczak G., Frey S.H., A Common Network in the Left Cerebral Hemisphere Represents Planning of Tool Use Pantomimes and Familiar Intransitive Gestures at the Hand-Independent Level, “Cereb Cortex” 2009, No. 19(10).

Króliczak G., Piper B.J., Frey S.H., Atypical Lateralization of Language Predicts Cerebral Asymmetries in Parietal Gesture Representations, “Neuropsychologia” 2011, No. 49(7).

Króliczak G., Westwood D.A., Goodale M.A., Differential Effects of Advance Semantic Cues on Grasping, Naming, and Manual Estimation, “Experimental Brain esearch” 2006, No. 175(1).

Lausberg H., Gottert R., Munssinger U., Boegner F., Marx P., Callosal Disconnection Syndrome in a Left-Handed Patient due to Infarction of the Total Length of the Corpus Callosum, “Neuropsychologia” 1999, No. 37(3).

Leiguarda R., Limb Apraxia: Cortical or Subcortical, “Neuroimage” 2001, No. 14(1).

Leiguarda R., Apraxias as Traditionally Defined [in:] Higher-Order Motor Disorders: From Neuroanatomy and Neurobiology to Clinical Neurology, H.-J. Freund, M. Jeannerod, M. Hallett, R. Leiguarda (eds.), Oxford 2005.

Leiguarda R., Marsden C.D., Limb apraxias: Higher-order Disorders of Sensorimotor Integration, “Brain” 2000, No. 123.

Liepmann H., Das Krankheitshild der Apraxie (Motorischen/Asymbolie), “Monatschrift fur Psychiatrie und Neurologie” 1900, No. 8.

Liepmann H., Apraxia, “Ergebn. Ges. Med.” 1920, No. 1.

Liepmann H., Mass O., Fall von linksseitiger Agraphie und Apraxie bei rechsseitiger Lahmung, “Zeitschrift fur Psychologie und Neurologie” 1907, No. 10.

Margolin D., Right Hemisphere Dominance for Praxis and Left Hemisphere Dominance for Speech in a Left-hander, “Neuropsychologia” 1980, No. 18(6).

Martin K., Jacobs S., Frey S.H., Handedness-Dependent and-Independent Cerebral Asymmetries in the Anterior Intraparietal Sulcus and Ventral Premotor Cortex During Grasp Planning, “Neuroimage” 2011, No. 57(2).

Meador K., Loring D.W., Lee K., Hughes M., Lee G., Nichols M., Heilman K.M., Cerebral Lateralization: Relationship of Language and Ideomotor Praxis, “Neurology” 1999, No. 53(9).

Moll J., de Oliveira-Souza R., Passman L.J., Cunha F.C., Souza-Lima F., Andreiuolo P.A., Functional MRI Correlates of Real and Imagined Tool-Use Pantomimes, “Neurology” 2000, No. 54(6).

Morlass J., Contribution a l’Etude de l’Apraxie, Paris 1928.

Ochipa C., Rothi L.J., Heilman K.M., Ideational Apraxia: a Deficit in Tool Selection and Use, “Ann Neurol” 1989, No. 25(2).

Ohgami Y., Matsuo K., Uchida N., Nakai T., An fMRI Study of Tool-use Gestures: Body Part as Object and Pantomime, “Neuroreport” 2004, No. 15(12).

Poeck K., Kerschensteiner M., Ideomotor Apraxia Following Right-sided Cerebral Lesion in a Left-handed Subject, “Neuropsychologia” 1971, No. 9(3).

Rapcsak S., Gonzalez Rothi L.J., Heilman K.M., Apraxia in a Patient with Atypical Cerebral Dominance, “Brain Cogn” 1987, No. 6(4).

Rapcsak S., Ochipa C., Beeson P.M., Rubens A.B., Praxis and the Right Hemisphere, “Brain Cogn” 1993, No. 23(2).

Rocca M., Falini A., Comi G., Scotti G., Filippi M., The Mirror-Neuron System and Handedness: A “Right” World?, “Human Brain Mapping” 2008, No. 29(11).

Roeltgen D., Heilman K.M., Apractic Agraphia in a Patient with Normal Praxis, “Brain Lang” 1983, No. 18(1).

Rothi L., Heilman K.M., Watson R.T., Pantomime Comprehension and Ideomotor Apraxia, “J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry” 1985, No. 48(3).

Rothi L., Ochipa C., Heilman K.M., A Cognitive Neuropsychological Model of Limb Praxis, “Cognitive Neuropsychology” 1991, No. 8(6).

Roy E., Square-Storer P., Hogg S., Adams S., Analysis of task demands in apraxia, “Int J Neurosci” 1991, No. 56(1 – 4).

Rumiati R., Weiss P.H., Shallice T., Ottoboni G., Noth J., Zilles K., Fink G.R., Neural Basis of Pantomiming the Use of Visually Presented Objects, “Neuroimage” 2004, No. 21(4).

Stamenova V., Roy E.A., Black S.E., Associations and Dissociations of Transitive and Intransitive Gestures in Left and Right Hemisphere Stroke Patients, “Brain & Cognition” 2010, No. 72(3).

Valenstein E., Heilman K.M., Apraxic Agraphia with Neglect-induced Paragraphia, “Arch Neurol” 1979, No. 36(8).

Van Essen D., A Population-Average, Landmark- and Surface-based (PALS) Atlas of Human Cerebral Cortex, “Neuroimage” 2005, No. 28(3).

Villarreal M., Fridman E.A., Amengual A., Falasco G., Gerscovich E.R., Ulloa E R., Leiguarda R.C., The Neural Substrate of Gesture Recognition, “Neuropsychologia” 2008, No. 46(9).

Vingerhoets G., Knowing about Tools: Neural Correlates of Tool Familiarity and Experience, “Neuroimage” 2008, No. 40(3).

Vingerhoets G., Acke F., Alderweireldt A.S., Nys J., Vandemaele P., Achten E., Cerebral Lateralization of Praxis in Right- and Left-handedness: Same Pattern, Different Strength, “Human Brain Mapping” 2012, No. 33(4).

Vingerhoets G., Acke F., Vandemaele P., Achten E., Tool Responsive Regions in the Posterior Parietal Cortex: Effect of Differences in Motor Goal and Target Object During Imagined Transitive Movements, “Neuroimage” 2009, No. 47(4).

Vingerhoets G., Alderweireldt A.S., Vandemaele P., Cai Q., Van der Haegen L., Brysbaert M., Achten E., Praxis and Language Are Linked: Evidence from Co-lateralization in Individuals with Atypical Language Dominance, “Cortex” 2013, No. 49.

Vingerhoets G., Vandekerckhove E., Honore P., Vandemaele P., Achten E., Neural Correlates of Pantomiming Familiar and Unfamiliar Tools: Action Semantics Versus Mechanical Problem Solving?, “Human Brain Mapping” 2011, No. 32(6).

Volkmann J., Schnitzler A., Witte O.W., Freund H., Handedness and Asymmetry of Hand Representation in Human Motor Cortex, “J Neurophysiol” 1998, No. 79(4).

Watson R., Heilman K.M., Callosal Apraxia, “Brain” 1983, No. 106.

Yu-Huan H., Ying-Guan Q., Gui-Quing Z., Crossed Aphasia in Chinese: A Clinical Survey, “Brain and Language” 1990, No. 39.


Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.